Restoring Coloured pages

Discuss the original adventures of the Red Shadows and Action Force!
Post Reply
Malcolm Orr
Red Shadow
Red Shadow
Posts: 951
Joined: 30 Nov 2008 18:27

Restoring Coloured pages

Post by Malcolm Orr »

Hi, I hope people don't mind me posting this. I'm thinking of restoring the BAF01 comic 'Action Force' and thought I'd post some ideas of how to enhance vintage coloured material.

1. Levels

In photoshop, select:

Enhance (from the top bar) > adjust lighting > levels

and the levels box will appear.

The input levels are the top slider and have a graph above them. There are three arrows you can move under the x axis. The far left one controls how dark the darkest colours are, the far right one how bright the brightest colours are, and the middle arrow the balance between the two.

Compare both pictures - move the two outside arrows to get the bright and dark areas how you want them, then tweak the middle one to reach the right balance.

Advanced tip: you can just alter these settings for each of the red, green and blue components and altering the middle arrow particularly removes colour casts.

After that a very gentle smart blur sometimes tidies the picture.

Image


2. Restoring letters

Browned and smudged paper often leads to difficult letters. You can white the area out and then replace with a font, but here's a way of tidying the text.

Alter the levels as above to acheive optimal appearance (you will have likely done this already)

Choose the icon on the left side where the red circle is (sponge tool). That brings up the sponge tool bar on the top.

There are three tools - the sponge tool, the dodge tool and the burn tool

Sponge tool - either increases or decreases the saturation of the area brushed. You can see in the pic below how it virtually eliminated the brown. In this example, that's all that is really needed, but I've done the next two steps as well.

Dodge tool - makes things brighter. For lettering use this on 'highlights' with an exposure of 25%. It make the highlights brighter (so will leave the dark letters alone). Eseentially it eliminated light greys. Use it too much and you get raggy edged letters.

Burn tool - makes things darker. Set on 'shadows' with similar exposure. It'll leave the white and darken the darks, so particularly it'll make darh grey black.

You choose the desaturation first, then dodge, then burn usually. Dodge and burn on those settings are also good for adding depth to comic book figures too.

Image

Malcolm Orr
Red Shadow
Red Shadow
Posts: 951
Joined: 30 Nov 2008 18:27

Re: Restoring Coloured pages

Post by Malcolm Orr »

Also, if you see the SAS guys mask in the top picture, even after the levels have been done there's still light crimson/brown patches. The desaturate and burn tools on the settings above would make that black again without destroying the image.

User avatar
The Kraken Wakes
SCREEEEEEE!
SCREEEEEEE!
Posts: 5275
Joined: 28 Apr 2007 16:40
Location: Nottingham

Re: Restoring Coloured pages

Post by The Kraken Wakes »

appreciate the effort youve gone to in looking at this kind of stuff and experimenting with settings but I actually prefer the original images, I want it to look like that, but thats just me...
twitter - @thekrakenwakes / @BIronblood
instagram - THE_KRAKEN_WAKES

Malcolm Orr
Red Shadow
Red Shadow
Posts: 951
Joined: 30 Nov 2008 18:27

Re: Restoring Coloured pages

Post by Malcolm Orr »

I totally see your point. It's abit like the discussion on vintage Trek or Who - do you replace the old effects with new? Does one 'replace' the other? Is a newer and technically cleaner version reduce the nostalgia? and of course - how far is too far?

As long as the originals exist, then newer enhanced versions are also good - it provides options for the viewer. Of course any scan is already a processed version of that image and the computer manually adjusts the levels and it doesn't always get the most faithful or aesthetically pleasing view.

the real advantage of this is probably more in the area of matching coloured intro pages to the BFTB coloured B+W pages that follow rather than the already fully coloured stuff. It's also good for removing tears or stains.

But it's a valid point - restored/coloured adaptions or the originals?

(Of course the best answer is 'both')

User avatar
jamarmiller
I am Wilder Vaughn, I am the Black Major
I am Wilder Vaughn, I am the Black Major
Posts: 3923
Joined: 07 Mar 2005 15:58
Location: Fukuoka Japan---TAMPA Florida
Contact:

Re: Restoring Coloured pages

Post by jamarmiller »

thank you so much for posting this, I wanted to restore the 2nd volume of GI JOE Extreme and didnt know how to do this, volume one was already done by someone, but volume 2 was never done and now i can do it

Malcolm Orr
Red Shadow
Red Shadow
Posts: 951
Joined: 30 Nov 2008 18:27

Re: Restoring Coloured pages

Post by Malcolm Orr »

I'm currently restoring this 8 page comic. I'll send it to Baron and hopefully he will consider posting it as an alternative version???? The lettering is a bit like wiping a dirty windscreen (though I'm using a someone different approach to above)

User avatar
The Baron
World Enemy No. 1
World Enemy No. 1
Posts: 14726
Joined: 18 Sep 2012 05:10
Location: Secret HQ
Contact:

Re: Restoring Coloured pages

Post by The Baron »

Dude, don't bother! I'm planning to rescan that one on the A3 scanner as the page joins are awful.

They have all been through the levels and smart blur process once already...

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=2612&p=19400#p19400

Somewhere on the net is a very old torrent of the original raw BFTB scans, I'd love to get ahold of them if anyone has a set?

Malcolm Orr
Red Shadow
Red Shadow
Posts: 951
Joined: 30 Nov 2008 18:27

Re: Restoring Coloured pages

Post by Malcolm Orr »

The Baron wrote:Dude, don't bother! I'm planning to rescan that one on the A3 scanner as the page joins are awful.

They have all been through the levels and smart blur process once already...

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=2612&p=19400#p19400

Somewhere on the net is a very old torrent of the original raw BFTB scans, I'd love to get ahold of them if anyone has a set?
Whoops! Too late!!!

Anyway, it's more of an experiment. I've got a far too short attention span to colour, but I feel bad not contributing, so it's a test project to see if I can help in some way. In saying that I've sorted the one bad page join already. Also the levels are a lot better now too, as is the writing

(Out of interest for better writing I duplicated the layer. The top layer is the comic, the bottom layer is the lettering layer. On the bottom layer I did 'remove colour', adjusted levels much more sharply to get it crisp B+W, and then a fine blur to get it looking like original comic art lettering)

See what you think. It's just finished sending! (Of course it might all be a waste of time, but never mind! Also the smart blur is done in such as way as it won't give blocked egdes but will reduce grain)

User avatar
Chopper
This is what you get when you mess with the SAS
This is what you get when you mess with the SAS
Posts: 7221
Joined: 09 Apr 2003 08:30
Location: Melbourne

Re: Restoring Coloured pages

Post by Chopper »

I've been doing a bit of that to some degree with Kraken, because of the style of artwork it really needs it to match the existing colour pages. I've also been cleaning up the joined colour pages. Still plodding along, done 3 pages in the last week and cleaned up 3 joined pages too.

Mark

Post Reply

Return to “Battle - Action Force”